Case 20 · investigation · Medium · About 5–8 minutes
A courier submits four appointment cards to explain a morning’s movements. Vale knows that exactly one appointment was invented. The other three happened at their stated places and times.
Find the false card without guessing how quickly the courier walks. The case supplies fixed minimum travel times, and appointments take no time beyond the recorded instant.

The four cards
- A: Harbor, 09:00.
- B: Museum, 09:05.
- C: Station, 09:15.
- D: Gallery, 09:40.
Guaranteed travel limits
The minimum minutes between each pair of places are the same in either direction:
- Harbor–Museum: 10; Harbor–Station: 12; Harbor–Gallery: 30.
- Museum–Station: 15; Museum–Gallery: 20.
- Station–Gallery: 20.
These are complete minimum travel times, already allowing the quickest permitted route. Waiting is allowed. The courier used no other transport or shortcuts. All cards use the same accurate clock. The invented appointment did not happen and imposes no stop on the real route.
Which card is false? Show that the three remaining appointments can form a possible journey. Then explain why deleting any other single card still leaves an impossible pair. You need not identify an exact street route; enough elapsed time between consecutive genuine stops establishes feasibility under these rules.
The illustration supplies atmosphere only. No shadow, rail line, or unmarked paper in it adds evidence.
Hint 1 - reveal when you want a nudge
Look for pairs of cards separated by less time than their stated minimum journey.
Hint 2 - reveal when you want a nudge
There are two impossible pairs, and they share one card.
Reveal the solution and explanation
Card B, Museum at 09:05, is false.
A and B are only five minutes apart, but Harbor–Museum requires ten. B and C are ten minutes apart, but Museum–Station requires fifteen. Both impossible pairs include B.
Remove B and the real journey works: Harbor at 09:00 to Station at 09:15 gives fifteen minutes for a twelve-minute trip. Station at 09:15 to Gallery at 09:40 gives twenty-five minutes for a twenty-minute trip. Spare time can be spent waiting.
Removing A leaves the impossible B–C pair. Removing C leaves A–B. Removing D leaves both. Therefore only B can be the single invented appointment. The argument identifies a false record, not a reason why the courier invented it.
Solve another: The Cabinet of Fifty Mysteries · Browse all 50 cases