Thursday, October 22, 2026

The Harbor Gate’s Even Cargo

Case 18 · investigation · Easy · About 3–6 minutes

Three wooden trays contain, from left to right, two, three, and five brass counters.
Counter counts and tray order are the complete visual clues.

A torn release slip has halted the last cargo launch at Bell Quay. Three boats are ready, and the dock office has represented their loads with brass counters. The picture is the complete tally at the moment the slip was issued.

Vale must recover which boats the slip authorized. Choosing the biggest load is not enough: the harbor’s temporary release rule has two separate conditions.

The release rule

  • Each counter represents one sealed cargo unit.
  • The left tray records Boat A, the middle tray Boat B, and the right tray Boat C.
  • The slip released exactly two different boats. Their loads could not be divided, transferred, or left partly ashore.
  • Together, the released boats had to carry at least six units but no more than eight.
  • Their combined number of units had to be even.

Picture evidence

Count the separate counters, not the trays or marks in the wood.

Accessible evidence transcript: Boat A’s left tray contains two counters. Boat B’s middle tray contains three counters. Boat C’s right tray contains five counters. No counters overlap, and none lie outside the trays.

Which two boats were released, and how many units remained on the dock? List every possible pair to show why there is exactly one legal answer. The rule concerns cargo units only; it makes no claim about weight, safe loading, weather, or actual harbor regulations.

Hint 1 - reveal when you want a nudge

There are only three pairs: A with B, A with C, and B with C.

Hint 2 - reveal when you want a nudge

A pair can satisfy the six-to-eight range yet still fail the even-number condition.

Reveal the solution and explanation

Boats B and C were released, carrying eight units together. Two units remained with Boat A.

The complete pair check is: A+B gives 2+3=5, below the minimum. A+C gives 2+5=7, within the range but odd. B+C gives 3+5=8, within the range and even.

Thus each condition does useful work. The range excludes the five-unit pair; the parity rule excludes the seven-unit pair. The eight-unit pair is the only survivor. The tally contains ten units altogether, so releasing eight leaves two.

No boat has been accused of carrying a false load. The mystery is the lost authorization, and the closed rule plus the visible tally recovers it without needing an unseen document.

Solve another: The Cabinet of Fifty Mysteries · Browse all 50 cases

Famous Last Meals is now in paperback — stories, history and 25 recipes

Famous Last Meals: Stories, History, and Recipes is now available in paperback on Amazon. The illustrated collection brings together 23 his...