A loudspeaker can leave out a low frequency and still make a note seem to have that low pitch. This is not a secret subwoofer hiding in the room. A complex tone can carry a pattern of higher components from which the auditory system derives a pitch associated with an absent fundamental.
The surprise comes from treating pitch as though it were a label attached to one frequency in a recording. A recording contains physical pressure variations. Pitch is a percept. The two are closely related, but the missing-fundamental effect shows why they cannot simply be substituted for each other.

Start with three sounds
The short original signals below let you compare a reference with two harmonic complexes. Set a comfortable low listening level. There is no need to turn the volume up to search for a hidden bass sound. Depending on hearing, equipment and attention, you may hear the relationship more or less strongly.
1. A 200 Hz reference
2. A harmonic complex including 200 Hz
3. The complex with the 200 Hz component omitted
Listen first for whether the third sound seems to belong near the same musical pitch as the first, rather than asking whether they have the same quality. They do not: their timbres differ substantially. A shared pitch can coexist with a changed brightness or roughness. If you focus on a high component, the experience may differ again.
A pattern can survive a missing member
The University of New South Wales music-acoustics guide distinguishes a fundamental from the harmonics of a periodic sound. In the example here, higher components remain integer multiples of 200 Hz even when the component at 200 is removed. Their relationship still identifies a common repetition rate.
For the synthesis, 400 Hz completes two cycles in five milliseconds, 600 completes three, and 800 completes four. All return to their starting phase after five milliseconds. The combined waveform can therefore repeat at that interval without containing a sinusoidal component at the corresponding 200 Hz. “Repeats every five milliseconds” and “contains a 200 Hz sine wave” describe different properties.
This does not mean a brain literally runs the arithmetic in this paragraph. It is a description of information available in the stimulus. Competing accounts of pitch perception ask how frequency structure, temporal information and neural processing contribute under different conditions.
The researchers have to rule out shortcuts
One complication is distortion. A playback system or the ear's nonlinear responses can create additional components, including combination tones. A careful experiment must therefore ask whether listeners are using the intended harmonic relationship or an unintended cue.
Bonnie Lau and Lynne Werner's infant study tested missing-fundamental discrimination while changing spectral details, adding masking noise and limiting spectral-edge cues. These controls matter as much as the striking age of the participants. A response that survives relevant cue changes gives a different kind of evidence from a response to one unchanging pair of sounds.
The home examples here are demonstrations, not replications of that experiment. They do not include its masking conditions or behavioral procedure. Their value is to make the stimulus distinction audible and inspectable. They cannot diagnose an individual's hearing or settle a theory of the auditory system.
Keep the spacing, move the frequencies
There is a sharper test hiding in the relationship among the components. Start with three components at 400, 600, and 800 hertz. Now add 25 hertz to every component. The resulting frequencies, 425, 625, and 825 hertz, are still separated by 200 hertz. Their ratios to 200 have changed, however. They are no longer its second, third, and fourth harmonics.

This is ordinary arithmetic, but it creates an experimental opportunity. If a percept depended only on the difference between neighboring components, this manipulation would preserve the relevant difference. If another feature mattered, keeping the spacing fixed might fail to preserve the experience. In Micheyl and colleagues’ 2010 experiments, uniformly shifted complexes produced less consistent pitch matches and poorer discrimination than the harmonic comparison sounds under their tested conditions.
The calculator below makes the stimulus distinction inspectable without adding another listening demand. Set the shift to zero, then 25. Compare the adjacent differences with the displayed harmonic ratios. Its common-repeat calculation assumes ideal sinusoids with integer-hertz frequencies. It does not predict a listener’s pitch from that mathematical repeat rate.
Shift, spacing, and harmonic ratios
A silent frequency-table calculator separates additive shifting, harmonic ratios, and exact mathematical repetition.
Try a second prediction: multiply every original frequency by 1.1 instead of adding the same number. The new set is 440, 660, and 880 hertz. Its spacing changes to 220 hertz, and it remains a second–third–fourth harmonic series, now relative to 220. Adding and multiplying make different experiments even when both operations raise every component.
A separate 2009 study by Oxenham, Micheyl, and Keebler examined proposed timing cues in unresolved harmonics. Altering noise and stimulus level to make distortion products inaudible removed the evidence for that particular cue interpretation. The scope is specific: it concerns those tested stimuli and an alternative source of information, rather than disproving pitch perception from complex sounds.
That is a productive way to enjoy a demonstration twice. The first encounter asks what you hear. The second asks which physical relationship would have to survive a change for your explanation to remain plausible. A small frequency table can turn a surprising note into a much more exact question.
“Too high to carry pitch” was a testable assumption
In a 2011 experiment, Andrew Oxenham and colleagues found robust pitch judgments for harmonic complexes with fundamentals below 2 kHz even when all components were above 6 kHz. The authors used that result to challenge established limits in explanations of pitch. The finding concerns specified stimuli and tasks, rather than a claim that every high-frequency sound gives an equally clear note.
That kind of experiment reveals the scientific opportunity hidden in an illusion. Removing a component is not only a trick. It changes the evidence available to a listener in a way that can distinguish predictions. The result becomes more informative when the experiment specifies what remained, what was removed and which alternative cues were controlled.
A missing bass component leaves a useful distinction behind: the world delivers a structured signal, and perception extracts properties from that structure. Hearing a note is not always finding a matching line in a spectrum. Sometimes it is recognizing a relationship whose most obvious member is absent.
Sources and a closer look: UNSW: pitch, harmonics and missing fundamentals; Lau and Werner: controlled infant pitch experiments; Oxenham and colleagues: high-frequency harmonic pitch.
Explore art, experiments and other unexpected connections at Incoprea.